π
2023-07-18 Β |Β β±οΈ 25:27 Β |Β ποΈ 51.9K views Β |Β π 3.4K likes Β |Β π¬ 844 comments
Pea continues her legal series with Attorney Gracelyn Bellingham Bennett, this time covering the economic abuse provisions of RA 9262, contested vs. uncontested annulments, adultery and concubinage laws, child support calculations, the status of divorce legislation, and medical marijuana. This is the second half of their cohabitation law discussion, tackling the scarier criminal scenarios that foreigners rarely think about until it's too late.
Economic abuse under RA 9262 (Anti-Violence Against Women and Their Children Act of 2004) β
- If a foreigner (or any partner) prevents a Filipina from engaging in legitimate employment, that constitutes economic abuse β a criminal offense punishable by imprisonment
- The specific provision: "preventing the victim from engaging in any legitimate profession, occupation, business, or activity"
- You cannot make your partner financially dependent on you and then withdraw support
- Gracie's advice on protecting yourself: gather evidence showing you did NOT prevent her from working β for example, if you sent her job listings on Facebook and she replied "I don't want to work," save those messages
- Pea raises the concern that a Filipina could get her large family (mom, brothers, barangay neighbors) to all testify that the foreigner prevented her from working; Gracie acknowledges this but emphasizes that the burden of proof is on the Filipina β she has to present concrete evidence, not just witnesses telling a coordinated story
- Extreme scenario: What if a diabolical Filipina files a false economic abuse complaint to extort money? Gracie walks through the process β a complaint goes to a prosecutor first for preliminary investigation to determine probable cause; only then does it go to court; only after court proceedings can a hold departure order be issued
- Practical reality: the process from complaint to court takes at least six months, giving the foreigner time to leave the Philippines before a hold departure order is issued
- Gracie confirms that in practice, many foreigners in this situation simply leave the country once they're served notice of a complaint β "if he doesn't want to undergo those tedious processes... that might be the wise decision"
Annulment when the ex-husband is uncooperative β
- A viewer asked about his Filipina girlfriend whose husband has been missing for eight years and won't sign annulment papers
- Gracie clarifies terminology: when the ex refuses to cooperate, that's actually an UNCONTESTED annulment (only the petitioner's evidence is considered); a CONTESTED annulment is when the ex actively participates and files an answer
- Annulment cannot be based on mutual agreement β it must be grounded in a legal basis invoked by the petitioner
- Gracie's insider tip: you CAN have an agreement with the other party behind the scenes, but if the prosecutor handling the case finds out about it, the case will be automatically dismissed β so keep any such arrangement quiet
Adultery and concubinage β the double standard in Philippine law β
- When a Filipina's ex-husband wants to extort a foreigner dating his wife, the typical threat is an adultery charge (which carries imprisonment)
- Key protection: if the ex-husband gives consent to the relationship, he can't later successfully prosecute for adultery β even if he files charges, the consent is a strong defense
- Recent real case: a foreigner was caught with his mistress by his wife and both the foreigner and the mistress went to jail immediately, then were released on bail
- The law is explicitly unfair to women:
- Adultery (charged against women): lighter burden of proof β just proving sexual intercourse or being seen dating in public can be enough; harsher penalties
- Concubinage (charged against men): much harder to prove β generally requires being "caught in the act" with very specific, stringent circumstances; lighter penalties
- Pea summarizes: "For a guy, just don't get caught in the act"
- Citizen's arrest scenario: if a wife catches her husband in flagrante delicto, she can invoke citizen's arrest on the spot, call the cops, and both the husband and mistress can be arrested immediately
- But even if caught having sex in a private location, the husband might still avoid a concubinage conviction because the standard of proof is different β Gracie calls it "absurd but it's how it is"
- Pea's takeaway: "Don't get caught, or better yet just don't do it β it's not worth it... he can be apprehended even before he can finish zipping his" (leaves the sentence hanging)
Divorce legislation in the Philippines β
- The Philippines and the Vatican are the only places in the world without divorce
- Current status: still just a bill under committee in both Senate and Congress; Gracie can't say if it will pass in the current term
- It would NOT be a no-fault divorce like in the West β Gracie doesn't think Filipinos would accept "I just don't want to be married anymore" as grounds
- Everyone hopes it passes because annulments are too expensive and time-consuming for the many Filipinos who've been separated for years
Child support for foreigner fathers β
- A viewer is worried about being extorted through excessive child support demands because he's a foreigner with perceived deep pockets
- Gracie explains: if it goes to court, the requesting parent must itemize and justify the amounts; the court checks whether costs are reasonable based on the child's actual needs and cost of living
- The father's wealth is NOT the primary factor β the court won't approve 10,000 pesos for toys or 10,000 pesos for clothes just because the foreigner earns more
- There's no fixed formula in Philippine law β it's determined case by case based on circumstances
- Philippine child support law exists but is poorly enforced compared to Western countries where you can go to jail for non-payment
Medical marijuana in the Philippines β
- Still just a bill, same status as divorce β has been proposed multiple times but never passed
- Gracie personally supports medical marijuana with clear parameters but opposes recreational legalization, worried about youth access and experimentation
- Pea jokes that Gracie would be hilarious if she were high, and says she'll try it herself in Canada where it's legal
Pea's wrap-up summary of key takeaways (delivered after the interview) β
- Don't panic about inviting your girlfriend to live with you β a Filipina can't walk in and take half your stuff
- It takes five years of cohabitation to even be considered common-law, and even then she has limited claims β only to assets purchased together during that period
- She has zero claim to your bank account, pension, or anything acquired before cohabitation
- Protect yourself by making big purchases (condo, car) before the relationship begins and keeping everything in your name; keep receipts for appliances
- The economic abuse law (RA 9262) is the real surprise β document that you encourage her to work; Pea suggests either dating a woman who already has a job or "making videos of myself handing her the want ads every few months"
- These cases are extremely rare, but the protection advice is practical