Will You Give Me A Baby? A Filipina's Indecent Proposal

Pea's monthly mailbag episode covers three viewer letters: a Canadian expat whose neighbor is pelting his house with dog feces after he complained about trash burning, a man from Michigan whose Filipina girlfriend can't handle air conditioning, and a man who accepted a random Filipina's offer to father her baby and now — five years and a marriage later — wants to track her down. Pea delivers practical advice for each, along with cultural context about why these situations happen.

Letter 1: James S. from Canada — the neighbor war over trash burning ​

• James rented a small house in a provincial area for four months to test-drive Philippine life and immerse himself in local culture
• One Sunday, heavy toxic smoke filled his house; he ran next door to find his neighbor burning a pile of plastic bottles, a bicycle tire, and garbage bags in an open inferno
• The neighbor gave a blank stare and said "I'm burning trash, I'll be done soon" — no apology
• Two weeks later it happened again; James went to the barangay captain, who visited the neighbor — James could hear them talking and laughing through the wall
• Almost immediately things escalated: a dead rat appeared in James's backyard, then a used disposable diaper, then dark brown projectiles flying over the wall onto his house and roof — which turned out to be fresh dog excrement
• James is terrified of confronting the neighbor and feels the barangay captain may think it's funny
• Pea's response:
  • Burning solid waste in your yard is technically illegal, but people do it constantly and nobody cares — James is technically right but that doesn't help
  • The neighbor isn't retaliating because James is a foreigner — it's because James dared to complain at all; most Filipinos believe they can do whatever they want on their property and neighbors should just "suck it up buttercup"
  • The barangay captain was probably not laughing at him — most barangay officials take their jobs seriously and just want peace
  • If James only has a few weeks left, she'd honestly just move to a hotel in town
  • If he wants to fight: buy a cheap CCTV camera pointed at the back wall to document everything
  • He could go back to the captain or go straight to the PNP (Philippine National Police)
  • She wouldn't worry too much about physical danger — "Filipinos won't usually do anything bold like that, we just do the crap we think we can get away with"
  • Her best suggestion: call the landlord, explain the property damage, and let them handle the police — they speak the language, know the system, and James's name stays off the complaint forms
  • Closes with a joke: "it might be too soon to watch Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs"

Letter 2: Randall from Baguio — the thermostat wars ​

• Randall is from Michigan and keeps his apartment AC at 70°F; his Filipina girlfriend bumps it to 80°F every time she visits
• When he sets it to his comfort level, she says she "can't take it" and leaves
• Even in the car, turning on the AC makes her complain it's "making her sick"
• Pea's response:
  • Calls this the "thermostat wars" — it's an extremely common problem
  • Filipinos are simply accustomed to higher temperatures; their bodies are set to a different baseline
  • Many Filipinos genuinely believe cold air causes illness — this is a widespread cultural belief, not just his girlfriend being difficult
  • Pea's practical fix: compromise by turning the temperature down gradually rather than blasting cold air; the girlfriend will adjust over time
  • Bonus tip: turning the temperature down at night "guarantees you'll have a Filipina snuggle bunny till morning" — because she'll cuddle up to stay warm

Letter 3: Matt D. (no location given) — the baby proposal and its aftermath ​

• Five years ago, Matt (then 42, single) was at a small café in the Philippines before a conference when the waitress who brought his food said: "Will you give me your baby?"
• She clarified she didn't want marriage — she just wanted a mixed-race baby to raise on her own, didn't need his name, only wanted "his seed"
• Matt's first instinct was it was a scam or robbery setup, but something about her seemed genuinely innocent
• He admits he was lonely and "probably not thinking with the right head" — since he was leaving soon and never planned to return, he agreed
• She came to his hotel that evening; they had sex, and she asked to do it again the next day "to increase the chances" — he agreed to the encore
• They exchanged only first names: she said hers was Evangeline, he lied and said his was Charlie
• Now Matt is married (wife has a son from a previous marriage, no children together) and returning to the Philippines for business — he wants to find Evangeline and see if he fathered a child
• He only has her first name and the café where she worked five years ago
• Pea's response — first, why he shouldn't have done it (for other viewers' benefit):
  • Health risk: unprotected sex with a stranger is dangerous
  • Legal risk: the woman might actually be married, and sleeping with a married woman is illegal in the Philippines — her husband could extort him
  • Moral risk: even if the man doesn't care about an uncertain future for the child, many Filipinas aren't thinking clearly when they volunteer to be single mothers — they want a mixed baby but have no means to support one, and agreeing just adds another burden to someone who already has plenty
  • Pea confirms this kind of proposition isn't as rare as it sounds — she expects commenters will share similar experiences
• Pea's response — addressing Matt's actual question:
  • Challenges him to think through the consequences: if he finds Evangeline and there is a child, then what? Is he just going to say "oh that's cool, high five" and leave again?
  • What if she's single and desperately poor — will he offer financial support or just walk away?
  • What if she's married to an abusive alcoholic — is he prepared to rescue the child?
  • His marriage is a major concern: does his wife know about any of this? He mentioned telling his best friend, so Pea guesses his wife has no clue
  • If his wife doesn't know, is satisfying his curiosity really worth the risk to his marriage?
  • She suggests that if he's going to do this, he should confess everything to his wife first, get her blessing, and have a plan for every possible outcome before he goes looking
  • If he doesn't have his wife's full support: "let sleeping dogs lie"
  • Her core point: unlike the night he gave into temptation, this time he needs to actually consider the consequences before acting
  • She wants to hear what he decides

📺 Watch the full video on YouTube

🔔 Subscribe to The Filipina Pea